D.I.Y. Crayon Heart Favors

The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

Finished heart shaped crayons for a Valentine's Day favor

This blog post was originally published on February 8th, 2018.

Valentine’s Day is only a few weeks away and the kiddos are super excited about giving their Valentine’s Day favors to their classmates this year. We love a D.I.Y. moment in our household and these heart crayons were such a hit a few years back. The best news is they are very easy to make, inexpensive, practical, and the kids can help make them too!

I’ve been getting a ton of questions recently about what I plan on doing for Marlowe’s Valentine’s Day favors for her class at school.  This year we made something really fun, and it was so easy to do that I thought I would share in case it can serve as inspiration! These D.I.Y. Crayon Heart Favors were so simple to make, and you can use bits of broken crayons to make them—it’s like the ultimate recycled, re-purposed Valentine’s Day craft!

I also love the fact that it’s a kid-friendly Valentine’s Day favor that isn’t candy! I personally don’t mind if my kids eat candy on Valentine’s Day, but I know some other parents feel differently, and I want to make sure I’m respectful of everyone in the class. These festive and useful crayons are a great compromise!

in this picture

Step by step...

Step 1

Unwrap Crayons

Preheat Oven to 230ºF. If your crayons are already without the paper wrapping, begin to break the crayons into 1/2 inch pieces. If you’re using new crayons, use a knife to carefully slice down the paper so you can peel it off of the crayons.  (I unwrapped crayons for an hour and kept getting paper cuts under my fingernails before Kyle walked into the kitchen and was like “BABE!” Lol.) 

Step 2

Fill Mold & Bake

Fill your mold with multicolored crayons bits, and bake in the oven for 15 minutes. Do not overbake! You want the crayons *just* melted but not so melted that the colors start mixing together and creating crayon sludge.  

Step 3


Move the mold to a heat-safe surface, and allow to cool for 1-2 hours.  When fully cooled, pop the heart crayons out of the mold.

Step 4


Slip each one into a clear cellophane bag, and tie it with a tag.  I wrote on the tags: “You Make My Life More COLORFUL. xoxo Marlowe”

in this picture

Photographs by Courtney Ann Photography / Happily Eva After, Inc. © 2018 All Rights Reserved

Share this post:

Leave a Comment:


  1. Maria says:

    How did you make the spiral?

    02.08.18 Reply
  2. Ravelle says:

    Amazing, adorable, perfect, charming, easy!!! Thank you so much for a non-candy, very affordable favor that kiddos will love!! My daughter has a severe peanut allergy, and even though he school is peanut free, parents forget to check labels on treats for peanut contamination. This favor would make her sooo happy!!! We don’t have time to make them, her party is tomorrow, (Valentine’s Day falls on Ash Wednesday this year and she goes to a catholic school) BUT! I love this so much, I gotta figure out another time to use them! (Also, I use a ton of exclamation points too, I think they are fabulous!!)

    02.08.18 Reply
  3. Anna says:

    I’ve made these about 4 to 5 times when my girls were younger!! LOVE it!

    Question: which mold did you use to get those imprints (swirls, dots, etc) in your hearts??


    02.08.18 Reply
  4. JMaggie says:

    Cute for adults too! Lol! Can’t wait to try these! I want to display them in a glass candy dish amongst some dried rose petals, as a V-day table decoration. So great it’s easy! Best kind of craft! ?

    02.11.18 Reply
  5. ru-chan says:


    09.30.19 Reply