Conversations With Kyle: Fatherhood Expectations

The following content may contain affiliate links. When you click and shop the links, we receive a commission.

Eva Amurri Martino laughs with her husband Kyle over an espresso

Marlowe and Major are my children, of course, but they are also parented equally by my lesser-seen but fabulous husband, Kyle! I’ve gotten so much interest from readers in how Kyle and I navigate the world of Parenthood together, and I thought it would be fun to start a new series on the blog where he and I can sit and discuss some parenting topics.  Welcome to the first installation of “Conversations With Kyle”! In this first one, we are tackling the concept of Fatherhood expectations.  I think Fatherhood has as many preconceived notions, culturally, that Motherhood does– and I was interested to hear Kyle’s insights and opinions on this one.  Our entire conversation is below:


Eva: Before we had kids, did you have a preconceived notion of how you would be as a Dad? Did you ever think about Fatherhood, or what were some of your ideas surrounding that role at that time?


Kyle: It won’t surprise you that I didn’t have a ton of preconceived notions (laughs).  I think it really snuck up on me and surprised me– I didn’t start really giving it a lot of thought until the first sonogram we did with Marlow that looked like an actual child.  I remember when we left the doctor’s office that day I was kind of losing it, and it surprised you because you had obviously been thinking about it for so long and it was so real to you before it was to me.  And that was the first moment I started really thinking about the Dad I wanted to be…and I think I was overwhelmed by the reality that I was going to be a Father.  I didn’t think really about the things I wanted to do– I was more overcome by the Dad I didn’t want to be. 


Eva: Right! When you were a kid did you ever think about that? When did you think to yourself that you even wanted to be a Dad? Did you just assume that you would be a Dad one day?


Kyle:  I think I just assumed.  I think more it would be that I would have to think about NOT being a Dad.  I just expected it I guess.  I think what makes it hard– and I don’t want to stereotype and say it’s men, I’ll just say it’s me– I just lived in a very egocentric world and I didn’t really open up to the idea of loving something and caring about something more than myself.  And having my first kid was the first time that that idea was not just a thought, but an actual feeling– it just happened to me that I felt that way.


Eva:  Leading in to that… I’ve always said that becoming a Mother is a revolutionary experience.  I feel like my life and how I looked at life just changed on a dime the minute Marlowe was born.  Did you feel that way? Or was that something that happened more gradually? How did that feel for you?


Kyle: Her birth was– and I mean I can’t really describe because it’s never happened to me before, and it’s also never happened to me again.  Major’s birth was different for some reason.  But in a weird way, it felt like my birth too.  It felt like I was starting a new life, and it felt very disjointing but euphoric.  There was a high for sure, and then there was a coming down off of that that was actually… confusing.  The first moment was so spectacular and high that the fog I went in to after that felt very incongruous– and I think it was just because I noticed the bond that you two were having, and I didn’t feel like I was a part of that– from both of you in your own little world. And I think that I didn’t want to interrupt that, and that was part of my more conscious thought…and then more of my subconscious feeling was feeling left out.


Eva: Yeah, I think that sometimes women don’t understand that men can have a really visceral experience during birth that then sometimes doesn’t feel like it has a place to land– do you know what I mean? Like how you were just saying that you know, afterwards we as Moms have a very culturally-understood role and place in the postpartum family.  But for men, that experience– it doesn’t really have a space that is culturally understood to land and so maybe as a Dad it’s possible to feel misunderstood and unmoored a bit trying to navigate those feelings and experiences.  It’s not as talked-about.


Kyle: Well, and what’s weird too– you know, Romantics talk about soulmates and Destiny and all these cosmic connections…it was weird to watch a soulmate encounter happen while you’re in the room.  I watched you and Marlowe meet, and you guys were soulmates.  It was clear right from the start that your connection didn’t start then– but it did for me.  I felt like I was late in a way, you know?


Eva: Do you think that that can add to the difficulty sometimes in transitioning in to Fatherhood for men? That there’s all this joy but it also comes with feelings of isolation maybe? Like feeling a little bit lonely and not being able to really communicate that?


Kyle: Well I think what happens, too, is sometimes issues in a relationship that are either dormant or have become part of the norm– they metastasize and can become really harmful in those moments…because there’s so much energy and there’s a dynamic shift that you can’t anticipate.  And I can’t speak for men in general– but for me I think a lot of resentments or insecurities just magnified in those first few months after Lowie was born– because I just felt really insignificant and didn’t feel like I had the same connection that I recognized between the two of you. I questioned if I was doing it wrong.


Eva: I definitely get that.  So, what’s your favorite part about Fatherhood? If you had to distill it to one concept or dynamic what would you say?


Kyle:  I think the things I love the most are the forgiveness and the appreciation.  You know, kids forgive you if you aren’t the most perfect person every day– and they appreciate the smallest things and details that we grownups could have missed.  And nothing beats coming home after work, and before they see me they hear my voice– and I can hear them yelling “Dad!” To be received that way, with that joy, constantly….I wish I could bottle that up.


Eva: So sweet.  So what was the transition from one to two kids like for you? How was that different that what you had anticipated?


Kyle: Well, we laughed about the fact that I felt parenting was hard for the first time…because I actually had to start parenting at that point… (laughs)


Eva: Mmmm hmmm…Like every single thing you were like “Why is this so hard? Newborns are so hard!” And I was like welcome to the club, buddy. (laughs).  I was like “It isn’t this round that’s hard! You’re just here doing it for the first time.” 


Kyle: Exactly.  Whoops. (laughs)  What was great about having two though was that I got to know Lowie a lot better– and we developed a much  stronger bond during the beginning of Major’s life. I definitely think that was when I recognized how distant you and I had become, too.  With the first I think we did a really good job at recognizing the moments where our life had changed and distanced us and then put things in place– whether it be Date Nights or just cuddling on the couch watching a show– and with two kids those moments were much more sporadic and I think we didn’t arrest that.


Eva: I agree with that! (laughs) So, how has Fatherhood been different as an experience or as a role than you imagined?


Kyle:  I think I’ve recognized the facade of being a parent.  As a kid you don’t see your parents as scared, or without answers, you know? You see them as unflappable.  And that was the thing that I noticed– not only is it NOT easy, but there is no playbook, and you…


Eva: …and you never know if you’re doing the right thing? (laughs)


Kyle: You NEVER know if you’re doing the right thing (laughs). And I realized that sometimes with parenting it’s about surrendering to the idea of imperfection. Because then not much scares you– when you’re ok learning on the job.  I think that was the big surprise.  I’m still not the parent I’m going to be…it’s a constantly evolving process and you’re tweaking and testing…and there’s just a lot of trial and error.  What’s good is that it’s in the most authentic moments, when you’re not trying to be the perfect parent, that I think you make the strongest connections with your kids.


Eva:  Yeah, definitely.  So even in this “learning on the job”, do you have any advice for new fathers? Things that either you wish somebody had told you, or that you wish you could have done differently?


Kyle:  With the first kid I would I could have known to take a back seat a little bit– and to understand that it’s not about you…in a good way.  You can ride that first tough period by not retreating, but by actually leaning in to the discomfort of the transition and finding ways to help out.  I mean I remember looking at you breastfeeding and thinking “she is literally keeping this kid alive…and I’ve, like, changed a diaper”.  You know? It’s unusual for a father, I think, to take such a supporting role.  But you can really live in what’s needed in that moment and not let it hurt you even if it makes you feel left out a bit. 


Eva: Right, like taking orders as opposed to giving orders. 


Kyle: Yeah.  And also not blaming yourself or thinking that there’s something wrong with you if you don’t have the connection your wife does with your kid right at the same time with the same intensity.  And remember that you’re there to support two people.  You know, there are two people that are going through something and need you– and I think you can find a strength in knowing this is your time to show up for those people and be selfless….which I didn’t do great at. (laughs)


Eva: (laughing) Yeah.  There was a learning curve in the Marlowe era for sure. (laughs) I was literally sitting here thinking “So…any regrets, Kyle?” Ha! I think people can relate to that, though.  That’s why conversations like this are important.  People don’t talk about it enough or know what to expect. 


Kyle:  I also regret trying to “be a good dad” right at the beginning.  You know what I mean? Like being frustrated at myself for not getting things right right at the start.  Being “right” shouldn’t really come in to your thought process at the beginning.  I think finding your own new rhythm as a family, and listening to yourself is really important.  The hardest part about being a Dad is that it takes really good communication…


Eva: Do you mean with your partner or with your kids?


Kyle: Your partner, your kids, and yourself.  Really understanding yourself, too, and why you’re feeling a certain way.  Getting to the root of that. Why am I finding this hard? What am I insecure about? Why am I getting frustrated? And then, understanding that every Dad is sitting there going through some version of that.  It’s a collective experience. 


Eva: Thank you so much for sharing yours with me today!


Kyle: You’re welcome


Eva Amurri Martino breastfeeds her new son Major after her home birth in Connecticut while her husband Kyle watches on sweetly

Kyle Martino stares lovingly into his wife Eva Amurri Martino while she plays with her hair at a restaurant

Eva Amurri Martino whispers into her husband Kyle's ear while they drink espresso

Kyle Martino stares lovingly into his wife Eva Amurri Martino while she plays with her hair at a restaurant


Photographs by Carter Fish

Share this post:

Leave a Comment:


  1. Amy says:

    WOW Eva and Kyle!!!!! (Yes, I’m using all the exclamation points ?). This is so powerful not only for a new father, but also for a mother to see things from this perspective. I have three kids and still learned something here. I can absolutely see my husband saying all the same things, but having a harder time articulating them. Ha! Thank you!

    03.29.18 Reply
    • Thank you so much! I really feel that it’s so interesting (and important), as a woman to really take the time to listen to the male perspective. I think as moms a lot of times we tend to project our assumptions about the fatherhood experience because they don’t share as freely as we do!

      04.03.18 Reply
  2. Areth Tsouprake says:

    Very inciteful! Thanks for sharing your thoughts Kyle and Eva

    03.29.18 Reply
    • Brigit says:

      Very insightful and, great interview.

      03.29.18 Reply
    • thanks!

      04.03.18 Reply
  3. Samantha says:

    Loved the comment about forgiveness and appreciation being his favorite part of fatherhood. Spot on for me as a mother too.

    03.29.18 Reply
    • Glenda says:

      Yes yes yes!!!!

      03.29.18 Reply
  4. Angela says:

    I could not love this more! This touched my heart and was so real. Thank you so much for sharing! You both truly are amazing! Thank you again!

    03.29.18 Reply
  5. Martina MacKenzie says:

    I really enjoyed this piece. I can see why you said in your IG stories that it was a very good conversation for you two to have! Thank you for sharing.

    03.29.18 Reply
  6. Selena says:

    I loved this so much! And you’re right, what a tear-jerker. It is so wonderful to hear such an honest account of being a father for the first and second time. Thank you Kyle and Eva!

    03.29.18 Reply
  7. Glenda says:

    Wow… wow…wow…. SOoo very true Kyle. Thank you for your honesty! I love it! It’s an on the job training for both parents. I love how he describes the “soulmate”. I totally agree for a mother it starts the minute we find out we’re pregnant, for the dad I truly believe it starts when the child is born and the hands on bonding experience starts.

    03.29.18 Reply
    • I think this discrepancy between when mothers feel like a parent and when fathers do is actually a big factor in the disconnect between partners when a woman suffers a miscarriage. Oftentimes the father has a different emotional experience and it’s hard to connect– at least it was for Kyle and I with my miscarriage. Such important things to talk about though!

      04.03.18 Reply
  8. Esme says:

    Wow, love this new section! Thank you both for sharing your thoughts, it’s reassuring to hear other parents going through these emotions. Like both of you said, communication is the KEY to understanding each other during the shift from couple to family. My husband and I can totally relate to what Kyle said about living an egocentric world before you have kids, not only as an individual but also as a couple. Everything revolved around what we wanted to do, where we wanted to go, how we were going to do it. Once that child comes, all the attention (as it should) goes to them and you sometimes lose your identity for yourself and as a couple. communicating and being as honest as we could helped us to reestablish our new roles as parents but also redefined our relationship.

    03.29.18 Reply
  9. Jess says:

    LOVED reading this. I’m about to be a mum for the first time & found it really eye opening to hear what goes on in the mind of a new dad! Can’t wait for more convos with Kyle in the future!

    03.29.18 Reply
  10. Brigit says:

    This was a very nice and, great interview for anyone wanting to be a parent either mother or, father. I think the feeling a Kyle expresses in the interview can probably speak bery much for other father’s and parent’s. Great interview. You both seem to be sensitive and supportive parents and couple.

    03.29.18 Reply
  11. Marnie McMahon says:

    Great post. Very honest too. Can’t wait to hear more. Now does Kyle cook?

    03.29.18 Reply
    • LOL. He actually doesn’t cook a lick. You can’t have it all hahaha

      04.03.18 Reply
  12. Ann says:

    You both are so authentic. It truly is what draws me to your blog and Instagram.

    03.29.18 Reply
  13. Meaghan says:

    This was great! My sister-in-law kept telling me “a father doesn’t really parent until the second child comes.” Also, I certainly noticed my husband and my oldest became closer after baby #2. Kyle is very insightful (perhaps from therapy). I need my husband to read this.

    03.29.18 Reply
    • I do think that different fathers are different, though, and it has a lot to do with the work you’ve done on yourself already and your own fathering.
      I know some men who jumped right in to action with their first and were very hands on, but I think typically it does take until the second

      04.03.18 Reply
  14. Erin says:

    What a great interview! And so interesting to hear from the man’s perspective. Thanks to Kyle for his candidness!

    03.29.18 Reply
  15. Carmen Ongay says:


    Thank you for being so open and willingness to share your experience and role as a father. I wished by husband had expressed his feelings about parenting 31 years ago. I wished I had been more perceptive.

    Great blog for young parents today.

    03.29.18 Reply
  16. Robin says:

    Thank you so much for sharing this

    03.29.18 Reply
  17. Rob says:

    My wife sent me this with the subject line:
    “you’ll appreciate this…”

    She was right. A lot of Kyle’s thoughts resonated with me.

    These 2 stood out:

    — “The hardest part about being a dad is that it takes really good communication.” —

    This one did not come naturally to me. What I not so quickly learned is that it’s MUCH harder to get through the beginning months with kids, when you don’t talk through things with your wife.

    Sometimes a 10-minute vent session is all you need (where your spouse just listens).

    And then other times, you have to violate the “don’t go to sleep annoyed” rule. Actually, you just gotta get some f’n sleep and guess what, you forget all about it the next day.

    — “lean into the discomfort and find ways to help out” —

    Spot on. You just have to accept that it’s just going to suck sometimes. Recognize and resist the urge to waaah, and just lean into it. Easier said than done, I know.

    Finding other spots to help and be useful actually makes you feel better too.

    I didn’t figure this out til our 2nd kid (about the same time I started drinking 4 cups of coffee per day).

    Having kids is the best, but man…it’s hard work sometimes. Good to know, we’re not the only ones winging it.

    Kyle and Eva, thanks for sharing this.

    It’s refreshing to hear real talk from another dad out there.

    03.29.18 Reply
    • Thanks so much for the kind words– I’m so glad it resonated with you!

      04.03.18 Reply
  18. Cari Guittard says:

    Well done. Excellent…. we need more father’s sharing their stories and perspectives. So powerful, relevant and timely. Please keep the conversation going!

    03.29.18 Reply
    • We will have another installment this month! 🙂

      04.03.18 Reply
  19. Vicky says:

    Thank you Kyle for being so open and sharing! I have three kids and I too learned some new things about a father’s thoughts. I think with each child it is a different experience and connection, because each child is unique. Such a great perspective on fatherhood.

    03.30.18 Reply
  20. Ashley Endy says:

    Thank you so much for sharing! Wondering if the things Kyle brought up went through my husbands mind too! hmmm ??
    Love following you and your family:)

    03.30.18 Reply
  21. Zoe says:

    This interview is incredible! To be so honest and forthcoming is amazing. On top of that, to be so able to look inside and be so reflexive and open to your own imperfections….I am blown away! Thank you, guys! I thought it was beautiful. So glad you shared this ❤️

    03.30.18 Reply
  22. Carolyn says:

    Awesome post and I can tell Kyle was very honest about his answers! This definitely helps put into perspective what my husband went through yet can’t/couldn’t put into words. Thank you!!!

    04.20.18 Reply